Lucinda Justice Hall

I think I am about ready to pull my hair out with this family.  I am trying to figure out which Lucinda be longs with what family and I am a bit perplexed by this Lucinda.

Lucinda Justice Hall, by all accounts of all family trees I have seen has her as the daughter of Jonathan Justice and Hannah Doty. This seems odd to me since Lucinda's family is living in close proximity to John and Edmund, both sons of John and Elizabeth Young.  I though she belonged with them since she is living near two other children of John and Elizabeth as well as the fact that she, being born in Kentucky, moved back with them, around the same time, to Virginia.  While I currently have no Lucinda Justice attached to John and Elizabeth, they did have an unaccounted for daughter who would have been born between 1810-1820.

Then, I began to do a little searching on Edmund and found that his second wife was a Polly Ann Hall, daughter of a William Hall and Lucy.  Most people assume that the Lucinda here is a Justice and that Polly is her daughter.  Edmund also has a son named Joshua who married a Rachel Hall, also a daughter of William and Lucy.  Again, she is assumed to be Lucinda Justice's daughter.  If this is true, then if Lucinda were John and Elizabeth's then that would mean Edmund married his niece and Joshua his first cousin.  The first cousin one I have no problem with but it was very uncommon to marry a niece.  So, this would make since for Lucinda to be Jonathan and Hannah's daughter.  

So, then I began to look into Lucinda more and found that there was no Polly/Mary Ann Hall or Rachel Hall living with William and Lucinda in 1850.  One would think an 18 year old and a 14 year old girl would still be living with their parents in 1850 if they did not marry until after that census.  I could not locate another William or Lucinda in that area who had a Polly and a Rachel.  

So, I expanded my search and I found something quite interesting.  There are TWO Lucinda Justices who married a Hall.  In Letcher County, Kentucky, just a few counties away, I found a Lucinda Hall, widowed, with her children and guess what?!  She had daughters Polly Ann age 18 and a Rachel age 11.  Pretty darn close if you ask me!

Now, the only thing that doesn't really work is that this particular Lucinda married a Jonathan Hall.  Her son, Jonathan, is listed as a Jr. in his marriage record.  I also have the following that identifies her husband as a Jonathan:

Book: 13th KentuckyCavalry, C.S.A. : Caudill's Army
By Ben Caudill CampNo. 1629
Hall, Jonathan J.: (3/13/1833-6/12/1916), Co. A, serv. prev.5th KY Inf., Co. F. pension states he serv. 5th KY Inf., Co. F. and 13th KYCav., Co. A. that he was disc. in Lecter Co. 1864 & was paroled on6/3/1865, res. Letcter Co. 1860, b. Floyd Co., s. of Jonathan & Lucinda(Justice) Hall, rec. KT Confed. Pension #675 & #3650 Knott Co. 1912, deaconin Mallett Fork Old Regular Baptist Church, m. Mary "Polly" Cook(1834-1920) 1850, d. Pinetop, bur. Watts-Cook Cem., Pinetop, Knott Co., KY.

Now, this Lucinda, who married Jonathan, is living a few doors away from Allison Justice, who is a son of Jonathan Justice and Hannah Doty.  If Lucinda who married Jonathan Hall is a daughter of Jonathan and Hannah instead of the other Lucinda, then there would be no issues if Edmund married Polly Ann since she would not be his niece.  

So, with everything said, is it possible that Lucinda who married William Hall is a daughter of John and Elizabeth Young and that Lucinda who married Jonathan Hall is the daughter of Jonathan and Hannah Doty?  Is there some record I am missing?

Sources

1850 Census:  Letcher County, Kentucky; Russell County, Viginia

Marriage Record of Edmund I Justice and Polly Ann Hall

Book: 13th Kentucky Cavalry, C.S.A. : Caudill's Army By Ben Caudill Camp No. 1629

Research of Thomas Harold Justice

The Hale Family - Stephen T. Hale

Stephen T. Hale was born on August 14, 1861 in Randolph County, Alabama. He is the son of Rachel Lurania Melvina Hale. Stephen moved with his family from Randolph County, Alabama to Carroll County, Georgia sometime between 1870 and 1880 where he married Priscilla Jane Levens on March 3, 1889. Priscilla was born on March 18, 1853. After marrying, the couple moved back to Randolph County, Alabama, and by 1910 had moved to Heard County, Georgia. Later, they moved back to Randolph County, where Priscilla died on November 15, 1937. Stephen died on March 1, 1955 in Randolph County. Stephen and Priscilla had at least five children: Claudia, Stephen Ruge, Sarah, Isaac and an infant son.
Their oldest child, Claudia, was born in February 1890 in Alabama. In 1920, she was still unmarried and living with her parents. It is unknown whether she married after 1920 or when she died.
Stephen Ruge Hale was the oldest son and second child of Stephen and Priscilla Hale. He was born on October 31, 1893 in Alabama. He married Minnie Elizabeth Huddleston some time before 1923. Minnie was born on September 9, 1898. They became the parents of the following children: Lorell, Sally Mae, Lowell, Alears R. and Raye. Stephen died on May 14, 1934. Minnie died on September 11, 1984. They were both buried in the Shadowlawn Cemetery in LaGrange, Georgia.
On September 22, 1895, the couple lost an infant son, their 3rd child.
Sarah Hale was the 4th child of Stephen and Priscilla. She was born in March 1897 in Alabama. She married first to a Mr. Johnson and had a son named Ernest in 1916. She married second to L. J. Hale. I do not know when she died.
Isaac Hale is the youngest son of Stephen and Priscilla. He was born on May 16, 1900 in Alabama. He married a woman named Nancy. Ike, as he was known, died on December 1, 1992 and is buried in Shadowlawn Cemetery in LaGrange, Georgia.

Ancestry Page

Sources
Census Records - 1870, 1900, 1920-1930 Randolph County, Alabama
Census Records - 1880 Carroll County, Georgia
Census Records - 1910 Heard County, Georgia
Death Records - Cellia Hale, Infant Son Hale
Grave Photos (Shadowlawn Cemetery)
Obituary of Sally Mae Hale Hall (Lagrange Daily News)
Obituary of Raye Hale Sherrer (Lagrange Daily News)